Monday, July 20, 2020

United States Schools Should Only Reopen When It's Safe

We had a very long school board session last week in Dublin, CA. They’ve been about 4-6 hours consistently over the last year, not just from COVID. My wife watches most of them. It’s like reality TV. There are characters, plot lines, and rivalries. Our local school board is in turmoil as half of our town is newer construction on the east side of town and half of the town lives in established neighborhoods from the 1980’s and prior. We’re building a 2nd high school because our existing one has 3k kids and growing. The east side of town wants to keep the tax money flowing into new construction of schools in the east, such as the new high school. The west side wants a balance of investment as our existing schools are older and need renovation.

Last week the school board revealed a change in plans to not reopen our schools for in-person learning. The prior plan-of-record had each family choose among three fully supported options:
* In-person 5 days a week
* In-person 2 days a week, remote 3
* Full remote
You could choose to move towards more remote later, but you could not move towards more in-person until the school board’s assessment of what it takes to keep school safe changes. The updated plan is for full remote learning for everyone for the 1st 6 weeks of the school year, and likely beyond that. I believe this is the best solution right now given the safety risks to kids and staff.

I believe it’s important to establish guiding principles for how to address school during COVID-19. Here are mine:
1. Prioritize safety over inconvenience.
2. Public health experts define safety.
3. Do what works.

My views are impacted by my wife’s work as a nurse in San Quentin prison for the last month part time. About 2 months ago they had zero cases. Then there was a botched prison transfer where COVID-positive prisoners were brought in due to incompetent testing and transfer protocols. Within a short time there was a huge outbreak among the 4k prisoners. San Quentin prison went on full lockdown with prisoners unable to leave their cells except for very stringent protocols. They try to minimize any ability for prisoners and staff to interact to minimize the chance of spreading. The positivity rate is now 59% (see below) despite going on lockdown with a much lower positivity rate. When you are indoors with infected people, COVID-19 will spread. Just as it did on cruise ships, restaurants, buses and church choir practice. Gatherings indoors are not safe without many precautions. You don’t have to be within 6 feet.

Here is a fascinating map of how COVID-19 spread from one dining session in a restaurant in China where they did extensive contact tracing. Note that the air conditioning airflow impacted who got infected and who didn’t. It wasn’t strictly based on distance alone.

This diagram created from using Closed Circuit TV cameras in Hunan China shows how a bus passenger was infected with COVID-19 despite not boarding the bus until 30min after the infected passenger had got off the bus.

South Korea just reported a study indicating children 10 years and older spread COVID-19 just as well as adults.

I understand the reasons why many people want our schools to open to onsite teaching. I want to do it as soon as it’s safe, which I don’t think it is now. For example, the recent Economist article “Let Them Learn” has basic facts wrong. They suggest a policy with remote-only learning does more harm than the risk of COVID-19. The Economist claims do not make sense in the context of this new study from South Korea.

The South Korea shows that 10 year olds and above are just as likely to spread the disease as infected adults, and therefore I believe the Economist claim is wrong to say that since kids aren’t “especially likely” to spread it more than adults and therefore it is safe. The Economist's claim about school staff from Sweden not getting COVID-19 at higher rates in other jobs is not comforting. We do not want school staff and volunteers to contract COVID-19 from school at all. We cannot have family members getting infected by kids. If the staff and volunteers don’t feel it’s safe, then many of them won’t return and we cannot have schools be effective without healthy staff and volunteers.

There are models that are known-to-work, such as Taiwan. Taiwan has children in schools and their economy is largely back to normal. Their response involves a collection of measures including strict quarantine protocols for those crossing the national border, widespread mask wearing with enforced fines, widely available cheap and frequent testing with fast results (say 48 hours and under), and contact tracing.

Meanwhile in the United States we are not enforcing quarantine during border crossings. We do not have widespread testing that gets results under 48 hours. We do not have a culture of wearing face coverings or national government guidance to temporarily step up face coverings to get the virus under control. Our outbreaks are currently too large to do effective contact tracing. If we want to make schools safe and stay safe, I believe we need to have a national plan that addresses these problems. Thinking about school as an isolated scenario from other parts of life doesn’t make sense.

Some politicians are trying to force schools to reopen. I am confident that regardless of political affiliation, families of school-age children will resist the push to send their kids to school given the COVID-19 risks. It just doesn’t make any sense right now. We should adopt policies known-to-work by other advanced countries and recognize that we can have a thriving economy and schools only we put in place a system that suppresses the virus and keeps our people safe.

43 comments:

  1. I will truly value the essayist's decision for picking this magnificent article fitting to my matter.Here is profound depiction about the article matter which helped me more.
    360DigiTMG supply chain analytics training

    ReplyDelete
  2. This is actually the data I'm searching for, I was unable to have requested a less difficult perused with extraordinary tips this way... Much appreciated!
    360DigiTMG

    ReplyDelete
  3. On the off chance that you are being mindful to gain proficiency with a few methodologies, at that point you should peruse this article, I am sure you'll get a lot of extra from this article.
    hrdf scheme

    ReplyDelete
  4. Supersite! I am loving it!! Will restore again, I'm taking your food in like manner, Thanks.
    difference between analysis and analytics

    ReplyDelete
  5. Stunning! Such an astonishing and supportive post this is. I incredibly love it. It's so acceptable thus wonderful. I am simply astounded.
    data science courses in noida

    ReplyDelete
  6. I am very enjoyed for this blog. Its an informative topic. It help me very much to solve some problems. Its opportunity are so fantastic and working style so speedy.
    best digital marketing courses in hyderabad

    ReplyDelete
  7. Crypto-currency as a modern form of the digital asset has received a worldwide acclaim for easy and faster financial transactions and its awareness among people have allowed them to take more interest in the field thus opening up new and advanced ways of making payments. Crypto.com Referral Code with the growing demand of this global phenomenon more,new traders and business owners are now willing to invest in this currency platform despite its fluctuating prices however it is quite difficult to choose the best one when the market is full. In the list of crypto-currencies bit-coins is one of the oldest and more popular Crypto.com Referral Code for the last few years. It is basically used for trading goods and services and has become the part of the so-called computerized block-chain system allowing anyone to use it thus increasing the craze among the public, Crypto.com Referral Code.

    Common people who are willing to purchase BTC can use an online wallet system for buying them safely in exchange of cash or credit cards and in a comfortable way from the thousands of BTC foundations around the world and keep them as assets for the future. Due to its popularity, many corporate investors are now accepting them as cross-border payments and the rise is unstoppable. With the advent of the internet and mobile devices,information gathering has become quite easy as a result the BTC financial transactions are accessible and its price is set in accordance with people’s choice and preferences thus leading to a profitable investment with Crypto.com Referral Code Code. Recent surveys have also proved that instability is good for BTC exchange as if there is instability and political unrest in the country due to which banks suffer then investing in BTC can surely be a better option. Again bit-coin transaction fees are pretty cheaper and a more convenient technology for making contracts thus attracting the crowd. The BTC can also be converted into different fiat currencies and is used for trading of securities, for land titles, document stamping, public rewards and vice versa.

    Another advanced block-chain project is Ethereumor the ETH which has served much more than just a digital form of crypto-currency Crypto.com Referral Code and its popularity in the last few decades have allowed billions of people to hold wallets for them. With the ease of the online world,the ETH have allowed the retailers and business organizations to accept them for trading purposes, therefore, can serve as the future of the financial system.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Here at this site actually the particular material assortment with the goal that everyone can appreciate a great deal.
    hrdf scheme

    ReplyDelete
  9. Our full Lace Front Wigs are all hand made with a lace cap. They are manufactured with thin lace sewn on top of the cap. Individual hairs are then sewn onto the thin lace. Each lace wig has lace all around the unit which will need to be cut prior to securing the wig to your head. You will need to cut along the hairline around your entire head. By doing so, you will be able to wear your hair anyway you like. You can even style ponytails, up-dos, etc. Once the Lace Wigs is successfully applied, it will appear that all the hair is growing directly from your head!

    Lace front wigs are hand-made with lace front cap & machine weft at back. Lace front wigs are manufactured with a thin lace that extends from ear to ear across the hairline. When you receive the wig, the lace will be quite long in the front. Cut and style according to your preference, as you will need to apply adhesive along the front of the wig. Once the wig is applied, you will still have Lace Wigs with a very natural appearance.
    TeamWigz Provide the Best Lace Front Wigs and Lace Wigs in Johannesburg and South Africa.

    ReplyDelete
  10. I think you have a point. Safety comes first and kids can take virtual class for the time being. School can arrange their online classes regularly and many other activities such as pollution speech or essay or other online activities can be conducted online. After its safe they can return to regular school.

    ReplyDelete
  11. I am stunned by the information that you have on this blog. It shows how well you fathom this subject.
    HRDF Scheme

    ReplyDelete
  12. Then it is followed by cleaning the data to remove the unwanted and duplicate parts of the data and also correct the erroneous bits and complete the incomplete data. data science course syllabus

    ReplyDelete
  13. I figure it could be more broad in the event that you get a football sports movement

    HRDF Scheme

    ReplyDelete
  14. Internet Download Manager 6.38 Build 10 IDM Crack Patch with Serial Crucial down load is a sort of shareware downloadmanager possessed by an American company called Tonec Inc.. IDM Patch Free Download captures any type of download in a extraordinary time limit and completes the download at a very brief time and at a faster speed as compared to any download manager right now. IDM company is based in nyc. IDM Download Free Full Version with Serial Key This computer program is readily designed for Windows OS just for now.
    Presently IDM Serial Crucial Free has turned into a renowned application with over 20 million clients around the globe. Internet download manager Hack may take downloads from many browsers like Internet Explorer, Microsoft Edge, Google Chrome, Opera, Firefox for practically just about any kind of record of user's choice. It has gained control over down load; nevertheless, it shows its dialog box to an individual.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Wow what a Great Information about World Day its exceptionally pleasant educational post. a debt of gratitude is in order for the post.
    data science course in India

    ReplyDelete

  16. Tongkat Ali ist eine Pflanze beheimatet in Südostasien. Sie gehört zur Gattung der Bittereschengewächse und Ihr botanischer Name lautet “Eurycoma longifolia”. Es gibt noch eine weitere Reihe länderspezifischer Namen
    wie z. B. “Pasak Bumi”, wie die Pflanze in Indonesien genannt wird oder “longjack”, die allgemeine Bezeichnung für Tongkat Ali Kaufen in den USA, Kanada und Australien.

    Das Ursprungsland von Tongkat Ali Kaufen ist Indonesien, daher findet man auch dort auch die größten Bestände. Weitere Vorkommen gibt es in Ländern wie Thailand, Malaysia, Vietnam und Laos.

    Die Einnahme von Tongkat Ali Kaufen empfiehlt sich insbesondere für Leistungssportler, die einen schnellen
    Muskelaufbau und Muskelzuwachs anstreben und nicht auf illegale und künstliche Substanzen zurückgreifen möchten um Ihren Testosteronspiegel zu erhöhen.

    Generell empfiehlt sich eine Einnahme von Tongkat Ali für alle Männer ab dem 30ten Lebensjahr, da in dieser Phase nachweislich die Produktion von körpereigenem Testosteron zurückgeht. Dies macht sich vor allem dadurch bemerkbar dass die körperliche Leistungsfähigkeit nachlässt, die Lust auf Sex spürbar abnimmt und dadurch allgemein das Selbstwertgefühl negativ beeinflusst wird.

    Mit der Einnahme von Tongkat Ali können Sie nachweislich Ihre Libido steigern, Ihr Testosteron erhöhen und Ihre gewohnte Lebensenergie aus den jungen Jahren Ihres Lebens wieder herbeiführen. Hier können Sie übrigens weitere Informationen bekommen zum Thema ‘Libido steigern‘ ganz natürlich. Sollten Sie daran interessiert sein lohnt es sich auch unseren Artikel über
    Butea Superba zu lesen.

    Tongkat Ali wächst als Strauch und kann Höhen von bis zu 12 Metern erreichen. Typischerweise dauert es 10-15 Jahre bis solche Ausmaße erreicht werden. Der Strauch trägt anfangs grüne Blüten die sich im Laufe der Zeit, bis zur Reife, rot färben.

    Allerdings sind die Blüten im Hinblick auf die Wirkung der Pflanze weniger interessant. Der wertvolle Teil verbirgt sich unter der Erde.
    Im Laufe der Jahre wachsen die Wurzeln teilweise senkrecht und bis zu mehrere Meter tief in den Boden, was die Ernte zu einer schweren und mühsamen Arbeit werden lässt. Je älter die Wurzeln sind, desto höher ist auch die Anzahl der Wirkstoffe Butea Superba.
    Von daher gilt es einige Dinge zu beachten sollten Sie Tongkat Ali kaufen wollen.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Testimonial Review of Taskade, Taskade Testimonials the all-in-one collaboration platform for remote teams. Unleash your team productivity with task lists, mindmaps, and video chat.

    ReplyDelete
  18. Recently, the keto diet has become extremely popular for its health benefits such as weight loss and preventing disease. A custom Keto plan for life! Visit here: keto diet usa

    ReplyDelete
  19. Health Experts have proven that regular exercise coupled with a good diet allow you to live longer and healthier. In this busy day and age, not everyone has the time to go to the gym - resulting to a lot of overweight people that desperately need to exercise. A healthy alternative is for you to Buy Home Gym Equipments that you can store in your own home or even at your office. Here are some tips when buying home gym equipment.

    First, know your fitness goals and keep these goals in mind when you are buying home gym equipment. One of the biggest mistakes that people make is buying the biggest or trendiest fitness machine simply because they like how it looks. More often than not, these end up gathering dust in your storage rooms or garage because you never end up using them. It is important to take note of what particular type of physical activity you want or enjoy doing before you buy your exercise machine. If you are looking to loose a few pounds and you enjoy walking or hiking, a treadmill is the best option for you. If you are looking to tone your lower body while burning calories a stationary bike is your obvious choice. Similarly, Special Equipments for Core Strength Exercises, Strength Training Weight Vests, Core Strength & Abdominal Trainers, Home Cardio Training, Strength Training Power Cages, Strength Training Racks & More.

    Second, set aside a budget before Buying Home Gym Equipments. Quality exercise machines do not come cheap. They are constantly exposed to wear and tear when they are used properly. So, pick machines that are built to last and have passed quality certifications to get the most out of your money. If you are operating on a tight budget, think about investing in several weights, We can Provide you High Quality Home Gym Equipments at Very Low Prices for your Complete Uses: Core Strength Exercises, Strength Training Weight Vests, Core Strength & Abdominal Trainers, Home Cardio Training, Strength Training Power Cages, Strength Training Racks & More.

    Its the Right Time to Buy Home Gym Equipments for you at Very Low Prices.

    ReplyDelete
  20. - Como organizar sua Semana com o Taskade - Segunda Feira, primeiro dia.
    - Como organizar sua semana com o Taskade - Terça - Vlog de Produtividade
    - Como organizar sua semana com o Taskade - Quarta
    Como organizar sua semana com o Taskade - Quinta - Vlog Produtividade.
    - Taskade - Sexta, Sábado e Domingo. Como foi e uma grande novidade

    ReplyDelete

  21. This is an excellent post I saw thanks to sharing it. It is really what I wanted to see. I hope in the future you will continue to share such an excellent post.

    business analytics course

    ReplyDelete
  22. It's late discovering this demonstration. At any rate, it's a thing to be acquainted with that there are such functions exist. I concur with your Blog and I will have returned to assess it more later on so please keep up your demonstration.
    data scientist course

    ReplyDelete
  23. Impresión online en gran formato, Imprenta digital online imprimimos roll ups, photocalls, vinilos, lonas. Envío gratis

    ReplyDelete
  24. We are a clean skincare brand, 100% organic and made with what the earth has given us first. Our product formulations came from listening to our ingredients. From their benefits, scents and results, our products are truly science of the earth. https://myblogu.com/profile/firstbaseskncare We wanted to step back from the long list of hard to pronounce scientific gibberish and provide ingredients relatable and understood. We are very proud to be one of the first few on the market to be ECO-Certified under the COSMOS standards, and for us we want to leave the earth better than we found it.

    ReplyDelete
  25. Buy Modafinil Online – Buying pills like Modafinil is not easy. Are you trying to purchase modafinil online? If your answer is Yes, then you are in the right place. In this buyer’s guide, we are going to cover everything you need to know about the most popular nootropic in the world.

    ReplyDelete
  26. Universal Gun sales is a trusted Firearm company base in Los Angeles California USA. It is one of the top Firearms Company in this part of the country. Buy Berreta 92x full size online They do offer the best firearms deal in the USA and to over 25 countries in the world. You can always visit their shop in Los Angeles using the address on their website. Place your order and get served by the best Firearm Company in the planet. Have fun.

    ReplyDelete
  27. Health Experts have proven that regular exercise coupled with a good diet allow you to live longer and healthier. In this busy day and age, not everyone has the time to go to the gym - resulting to a lot of overweight people that desperately need to exercise. A healthy alternative is for you to Buy Home Gym Equipments that you can store in your own home or even at your office. Here are some tips when buying home gym equipment.

    First, know your fitness goals and keep these goals in mind when you are buying home gym equipment. One of the biggest mistakes that people make is buying the biggest or trendiest fitness machine simply because they like how it looks. More often than not, these end up gathering dust in your storage rooms or garage because you never end up using them. It is important to take note of what particular type of physical activity you want or enjoy doing before you buy your exercise machine. If you are looking to loose a few pounds and you enjoy walking or hiking, a treadmill is the best option for you. If you are looking to tone your lower body while burning calories a stationary bike is your obvious choice. Similarly, Special Equipments for Core Strength Exercises, Strength Training Weight Vests, Core Strength & Abdominal Trainers, Home Cardio Training, Strength Training Power Cages, Strength Training Racks & More.

    Second, set aside a budget before Buying Home Gym Equipments. Quality exercise machines do not come cheap. They are constantly exposed to wear and tear when they are used properly. So, pick machines that are built to last and have passed quality certifications to get the most out of your money. If you are operating on a tight budget, think about investing in several weights, We can Provide you High Quality Home Gym Equipment at Very Low Prices for your Complete Uses: Core Strength Exercises, Strength Training Weight Vests, Core Strength & Abdominal Trainers, Home Cardio Training, Strength Training Power Cages, Strength Training Racks & More.

    Its the Right Time to Buy Home Gym Equipment for you at Very Low Prices.

    ReplyDelete
  28. BCT Consulting is proud to announce a new location in century city California. For the past decade, we have been providing web design, Los angeles IT Support managed IT support, and cyber security services to some of the biggest brands in Los Angeles.

    ReplyDelete
  29. Oferecemos os melhores serviços para seguidores, curtidas, comentários e visualizações no Instagram. Os serviços são entregues de forma rápida, segura e por um preço honesto e barato.
    Todos os serviços são iniciados de forma automática e você pode fazer um teste grátis de seguidores, curtidas e visualizações no Instagram.

    O Go Followers surgiu em 2015 e durante alguns anos foi o melhor e maior site para comprar seguidores, curtidas e comentários no instagram. Com o passar dos anos evoluímos e em 2021 lançamos um novo site simples e intuitivo para aumentar a experiência dos mais de 150.000 clientes atendidos.

    Nossa ferramenta envia seguidores brasileiros reais e ativos em sua grande maioria para qualquer perfil do Instagram. Escolha o melhor pacote para comprar seguidores instagram de alta qualidade. Você poderá escolher alguns pacotes como seguidores com curtidas, seguidores masculinos, seguidores femininos e seguidores automáticos.
    Todos os pedidos são feitos de forma automática e iniciam em poucos minutos após a compra, tá esperando o que?

    ReplyDelete
  30. The secret law of attraction dates back 5,000 years ago and it a natural law. It is not magic, but like magic and prays it is placing an intention to God or Universe to let them know what you want or need. It is a very powerful tool to change your life. fastest manifestation technique

    ReplyDelete
  31. I finally found great post here.I will get back here. I just added your blog to my bookmark sites. thanks. Quality posts is the crucial to invite the visitors to visit the web page, that's what this web page is providing.
    AWS Training in Hyderabad
    AWS Course in Hyderabad

    ReplyDelete
  32. Check out today’s coronavirus live update, the availability of the nearest hospital ICU bed, and the ambulance contact number in Covid Surokkha. Visit: ambulance service in dhaka

    ReplyDelete
  33. Diseñamos la página web para que tu empresa tenga una imagen digital profesional 24/7 y sea más fácil que te ubiquen online, puedan conocer tu oferta de productos, servicios, que logren contactarte de una forma más rápida y fácil.
    Nuestras páginas web son visualmente atractivas, tienen un diseño web responsive para ser visualizadas en un dispositivo móvil, lo que permite una experiencia de usuario agradable, intuitiva, simple, rápida y con usabilidad. Están optimizadas al SEO para ser leídas con facilidad por los motores de búsqueda como Google y ayudar al posicionamiento de tu contenido con las palabras clave con las que deseas darte a conocer.
    Al tener una página web de calidad te diferenciarás de la competencia al posicionarte en comparación con los que no tienen presencia digital, además de que atraer mayor tráfico a tu sitio web y permitirte mayor exposición que puede verse traducida en convertir a los visitantes en clientes e incrementar tus ventas. posicionamiento web barcelona

    ReplyDelete
  34. Offering Comprehensive Digital Marketing Services To Businesses Looking To Improve Their Online Presence marketing agencies philadelphia

    ReplyDelete
  35. Freelancers Incubator is a European educational institution specializing in the field of freelancing and fersonal growth. Become a freelancer

    ReplyDelete
  36. Really Nice Article! You post inspire me too much.
    lottery sambad from lotterysambad24hr.com

    ReplyDelete
  37. You completed several important tasks there. I looked into the issue and found that the majority of people will agree with your blog. Anyways, We offer Critical Essay Help in Uk for students who need homework help come visit our website I hope you will like our site.

    ReplyDelete
  38. Absolutely agree with your perspective. Safety should be the top priority, especially when it comes to our children's education. The examples you provided from other countries highlight the importance of a comprehensive approach – from testing to contact tracing. It's crucial to follow proven strategies for a safe return to schools. Thank you for shedding light on this critical issue.




    CALCULATERA

    ReplyDelete